Eli's Sampler Cheesecake Add-on



Eli's Sampler Cheesecake Add-on

Includes Shipping!
Adding to cart… The item has been added
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
ups logo
Standard shipping included in all prices.
Expedited shipping available.

Add one Eli's Sampler cheesecake to any 4 or 6 pizza pack. The Sampler includes three slices each of the Original Plain cheesecake, turtle cheesecake, white chocolate raspberry cheesecake and apple streusel cheesecake.

This item can only be added to a 4 or 6 DEEP DISH pizza pack. It will not ship on its own.

All items are final sale, but if an item arrives damaged or spoiled, please reach out to our team at (800) 568-8646 or fill out our contact form within 14 days of delivery and we will make things right.

Real Reviews from
Customers Just Like You!

77 Reviews
Write a Review
  • Posted by Jean R. on Jan 5th 2023


    Family says ots great!

  • Posted by Nancy A. on Jan 4th 2023


    Can’t really go wrong with Eli’s! Do wish you had the option of a plain cheesecake and not just the sampler.

  • Posted by LAWRENCE B. on Jan 4th 2023


    Was a gift for grandkids in Ohio they enjoyed the supries for Christmas & New Year.

  • Posted by David P. on Jan 2nd 2023

    Great Gift Idea!

    Pizzas and cheesecake make great gifts! All my out-of-town kids (no Malnati's where they live!) love them.

  • Posted by Jennifer P. on Jan 2nd 2023

    Good but inconsistent

    Our first cheesecake was eaten on Christmas Eve with guests and it was amazing we didn't read the instructions that we are supposed to let it defrost in the refrigerator and everything else we took it out the same day at the same time we took out our pizzas we had it sitting on the oven and forgot to move it when we turned on the oven so we put it back outside and it was fine it wasn't ruined it was great. We had the second cheesecake for New Year's Eve with guests. We followed the instructions for proper defrosting in the refrigerator a day or two beforehand and took it out of the freezer on the 30th late in the day and put it in the refrigerator. We are quite surprised when we took it out of the packaging on the 31st and it looked waterlogged and tasted that way too

  • Posted by Robert J. on Jan 2nd 2023

    Was really great

    Was really great

  • Posted by MARCIA J. on Jan 2nd 2023


    gave as a add on to the pizzas

  • Posted by Dorothy E. on Jan 2nd 2023

    delicious variety shared by three

    delicious variety shared by three

  • Posted by Cheryl W. on Jan 1st 2023

    Haven’t eaten yet but know

    Haven’t eaten yet but know it will be good because I’ve had before.