Beatrix Oh My! Caramel Pie



Beatrix Oh My! Caramel Pie

Add 2 Lou's Pizzas for $32

That's about what you'd pay at the restaurant!

Click the drop-down arrow to make your selection(s).
Includes Shipping!
Adding to cart… The item has been added
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
ups logo
Standard shipping included in all prices.
Expedited shipping available.

In a lineup of absurdly delicious pastries and desserts, Beatrix's "Oh My! Caramel Pie" takes the cake, er, make that pie.

Package Contents

Caramel custard filling piled into a twice-baked shortbread cookie shell. Beatrix's Oh My! Caramel Pie serves 10 people.

Remove cake from cyrovac casing and let it sit at room temperature for two hours.

With a soft touch to the sides, check to see if it has thawed. Cake is best enjoyed at room temp.

For a clean cut, dip your knife in hot water, and clean the knife after each cut.

After the casing has been removed, the cake can be refrigerated for next day enjoyment. For future use, keep frozen for up to 60 days.

All items are final sale, but if an item arrives damaged or spoiled, please reach out to our team at (800) 568-8646 or fill out our contact form within 14 days of delivery and we will make things right.

Real Reviews from
Customers Just Like You!

5 Reviews
Write a Review
  • Posted by Chad C. on Jan 18th 2023



  • Posted by George S. on Jan 4th 2023

    To experience

    To experience

  • Posted by Lotus J. on Dec 29th 2022

    Notes/card with Purchase not Delivered

    The pie was delicious but I ordered all the pies with a note and even a special card but none of these were delivered as such so if I had not checked in with the people I had it delivered to, they would not have known that the gift came from me. That's super sloppy and I paid extra for a card.

  • Posted by JILL R. on Nov 30th 2022

    Great Pie

    It was sweet and totally delicious.

  • Posted by Erin L. on Oct 5th 2022


    Talked to customer service, they said they would refund. It’s been weeks still no refund.