Brown Sugar Bakery Caramel Cake & 2 Lou's Pizzas


brown-sugar-bakery lou-malnatis-pizza

Brown Sugar Bakery Caramel Cake & 2 Lou's Pizzas

Choose Your Pizzas
Click the drop-down arrow to make your selection(s).
Includes Shipping!
Adding to cart… The item has been added
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
ups logo
Standard shipping included in all prices.
Expedited shipping available.

Award-winning cake paired with award-winning pizzas. Doesn't get any better than that!

Package Contents

Brown Sugar Bakery's 8-inch Caramel Cake starts with four layers of yellow butter cake so fluffy and rich, you'll smell the butter and vanilla as soon as you cut your first slice! The cake is luxuriously frosted in old-fashioned southern-style caramel that is so smooth and creamy, it'll take you back to a dessert you had at your grandmother's table. Enjoy with family and friends! Cake comfortably serves 14-16 people.

Package also includes two 9-inch Lou Malnati's deep dish pizzas.

Remove from cryovac and defrost at room temperature for a few hours. Place in refrigerator and enjoy.

All items are final sale, but if an item arrives damaged or spoiled, please reach out to our team at (800) 568-8646 or fill out our contact form within 14 days of delivery and we will make things right.

Real Reviews from
Customers Just Like You!

14 Reviews
Write a Review
  • Posted by Jackie C. on Jan 17th 2023

    Guests liked it but thought it was too sweet

    Next time i will order the chocolate one.

  • Posted by Carmelita H. on Jan 11th 2023

    Delicious! Really moist & good!

    Delicious! Really moist & good! Would love another one right now!

  • Posted by Todd B. on Jan 3rd 2023

    You shipped my order to

    You shipped my order to wheeling Fed Ex facility where it got shipped to Ocala Florida and was ruined by the time I received it. I live in Indiana. I believe this was fed ex fault and not tastes of Chicago. I will try company again

  • Posted by Debra W. on Jan 2nd 2023

    Brown sugar caramel cake

    Absolutely wonderful

  • Posted by Charles M. on Dec 21st 2022


    Cheesecake...excellentCaramel cake...cake excellent, but way too much caramel Sausage pizza......good Cheese pizza...not so good...cheese too chewey

  • Posted by Margaret P. on Dec 20th 2022



  • Posted by Barbara L. on Dec 6th 2022

    Great Gift

    My son went to college in Chicago and misses the pizza. He's always thrilled to get a delivery from you, Thank you

  • Posted by Ruth V. on Nov 29th 2022

    Pizza unedible

    I have used Tastes of Chicago for years to send an annual birthday gift to my son. Up until now, it has been great. However this time, the delivery was a couple of days late, the box was wet and the pizzas not only thawed, but not even cold. They had to throw them out. Wondering if they are using a new delivery service. To give credit where credit is deserved, I was provided a full refund quickly.

  • Posted by WILLIAM A. on Oct 15th 2022

    Icing to thick on top

    Icing to thick on top of cake.It made the cake to sweet.