Eli's Cheesecake Packages



Eli's Cheesecake Packages

Choose Your Cheesecakes
Click the drop-down arrow to make your selection(s).
Includes Shipping!
Adding to cart… The item has been added
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
ups logo
Standard shipping included in all prices.
Expedited shipping available.

Eli's rich and creamy cheesecakes are hand-decorated and baked with only the finest ingredients by people who care. It's the Eli's recipe for baking success.

Package Contents

Eli's 8-inch cheesecakes are available in two flavors: Original Plain or Sampler, with a variety of Eli's most popular flavors:

  • Original Plain
  • Turtle
  • Apple Streusal
  • White Chocolate Raspberry

Purchase Eli's Cheesecakes in quantities of two or four.

All items are final sale, but if an item arrives damaged or spoiled, please reach out to our team at (800) 568-8646 or fill out our contact form within 14 days of delivery and we will make things right.

Real Reviews from
Customers Just Like You!

16 Reviews
Write a Review
  • Posted by Phyllis C. on Jan 9th 2023

    Loved the Sampler

    My sister and her family loved the Sampler cheesecake. Know they would like another!

  • Posted by WILLIAM W. on Jan 2nd 2023


    Tastes greatTastes great Tastes great

  • Posted by Nancy G. on Jan 2nd 2023

    Eli's Cheesecake

    I have been ordering this for my brother & Family for about the last 4 years or so. It always arrives frozen and in good condition and they love the cheesecake. i had used another company and the other company had sent something I hadn't ordered and when it got to them it was defrosted. I will never order from that other company again! Eli's Cheesecake is the best!

  • Posted by Scott S. on Dec 27th 2022



  • Posted by THOMAS E. on Dec 21st 2022



  • Posted by Ronald L. on Dec 20th 2022

    Extremely overpriced

    Very expensive and customer service is nonexistent if you have any issues.

  • Posted by nat r. on Dec 19th 2022

    Tastes of Chicago Does Not Back Their Product

    The box was crushed, the cheesecake a mess and your company does nothing. I will never order again and take to social media to share my story.

  • Posted by SANDRA K. on Dec 11th 2022

    Awesome as usual

    Awesome as usual

  • Posted by MARTIN H. on Dec 10th 2022