Wildfire Key Lime Pie & 2 Lou's Pizzas


wildfire-steaks lou-malnatis-pizza

Wildfire Key Lime Pie & 2 Lou's Pizzas

Choose Your Pizzas
Click the drop-down arrow to make your selection(s).
Includes Shipping!
Adding to cart… The item has been added
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
ups logo
Standard shipping included in all prices.
Expedited shipping available.

Send a Chicago-style indulgence with two Lou Malnati's pizzas Wildfire's most popular Key Lime Pie, made with a sweet graham cracker crust and a tart key lime filling.

Package Contents

  • Two 9-inch Lou Malnati's deep dish pizzas
  • One 9-inch Wildfire Key Lime Pie
All items are final sale, but if an item arrives damaged or spoiled, please reach out to our team at (800) 568-8646 or fill out our contact form within 14 days of delivery and we will make things right.

Real Reviews from
Customers Just Like You!

9 Reviews
Write a Review
  • Posted by COLLEEN B. on Nov 4th 2022

    The worst

    I ordered for a gift it came 2 days late and was not frozen and I was not able to get anyone to answer my phone calls when I called . Will never order again

  • Posted by Maura H. on Oct 10th 2022

    Do not recommend

    Cookies were broken. Pie was crushed . 8 in pie barely. Not 9 in as advertised. Pizzas don't cook thoroughly. Customer service is terrible.

  • Posted by William G. on Aug 8th 2022

    Not a strong lime flavor for the price

    The key lime pie was delivered intact for the most part. We were disappointed that it didn't have a strong lime flavor even though the texture was great. However; I made a whipped topping and shaved some lime zest on it to give it some flare, and my wife and I really enjoyed it. So if you do get this, I recommend having a some fresh limes to boost the flavor (and to make it look fancy). We got this to celebrate our birthday since we were unable to go out to eat this time. It's hard to justify the price for what we got, but we did enjoy it after my alterations.

  • Posted by JOANNE F. on Aug 6th 2022

    Again delivered warm

    Not acceptable

  • Posted by Mary on May 3rd 2020

    Love love love this site!

    Spending my winters in Florida is even better with the opportunity to order our favorite tastes from home. I do it all the time. The pizzas are always delicious! Delivery is prompt and I love everything about it!

  • Posted by Jamie on Apr 30th 2020


    I've had lots of really great steaks. The steaks we received from Taste of Chicago were amazing. So good that I ordered 8 more..

  • Posted by Kimberly on Jun 4th 2015

    Perfect, as usual

    Sent my mom one sausage and one pepperoni, along with a key lime pie for Mother's Day. She grew up in Chicago and is now living in Florida, and she LOVED being able to have real pizza and said the pie was better than many of the local versions!

  • Posted by Don on May 18th 2015

    Definitely get this again

    The pizzas were a big hit and the cake was just the right size!!

  • Posted by Jared on Feb 6th 2014

    Not worth the money

    I was so excited to get your pizzas in the mail. We invited another couple over to enjoy them with us. I was very disappointed that the crust was all broken inside the tin and when cooked, they were WAY greasier than what we remember from our trips to Chicago. I know that I cannot expect the same pizza via mail order as I would in the restaurant however these were not even close. The key lime pie was delicious. However, it to had the crust all broken to pieces so the presentation was not so great. It almost seemed as though someone threw the box.